Triona's served its last beer at its original Gramercy location on Monday, September 28, during Monday Night Football, on a night the Chicago Bears beat the Eagles. Four days later the sports bar reopened next door, at 190 Third Avenue at East 17th Street, under a new name: Triona's Vintage Sporting Club.
On paper that is a move of a few feet. The building it moved into, though, has been a beer hall, an athletic club, a jazz basement and a brewpub. It is also a designated New York City landmark. The other big arrival this fall, the wine restaurant Amphora on East 20th Street, moved into a room with a record of its own, one that has served wine on and off since 1999.
A beer hall's old address becomes a sporting club
The Landmarks Preservation Commission designated 190 Third Avenue as the former Scheffel Hall on June 24, 1997, as Landmark LP-1959. The Commission's designation report dates the building to 1894–95, by the architects Weber & Drosser. Carl Goerwitz leased the property in 1894 and hired the firm to alter the building and join it to a rear wing. The report describes the result as a well-known German rathskeller and restaurant.
The Commission's report traces the building's later uses:
- 1894–1928: Scheffel Hall, the German restaurant. After Fred Ahrens failed to buy him out, William Allaire took over, and Allaire and his heirs ran the place until 1928.
- 1928: The German-American Athletic Club bought the 190 Third Avenue portion.
- 1969: Tuesday's took over the lease.
- April 1979 to 1995: Fat Tuesday's ran as a jazz club in the basement.
- After Tuesday's: The upstairs restaurant was leased to Highlander Brewery Pub.
- October 2, 2026: Triona's Vintage Sporting Club opened.
The name change isn't the only thing that echoes the building's past. Almost a century after an athletic club bought this address, a bar calling itself a sporting club has moved in. Eater NY reported that the new room has vintage sports memorabilia, more than 20 screens and an updated, Irish-leaning pub menu. It also keeps the bar's loyalty to the Bears and the Michigan Wolverines, which it built over 14 years at its first location.
The new location keeps long hours. Triona's lists Monday 3 p.m. to 2 a.m., Tuesday through Friday 2 p.m. to 2 a.m., and Saturday and Sunday 11 a.m. to 2 a.m. Weekend doors open at 11, early enough for the late-morning soccer window and the full college football Saturday.
East 20th Street's wine room, on its third try
A few blocks west, on Gramercy's side of the Flatiron line, 43 East 20th Street has spent most of 27 years as a wine destination. Veritas opened there in 1999 and became an oenophile favorite before it closed in October 2013.
The room's most recent tenant before this fall kept the same focus. Grub Street reported that chef Jared Stafford-Hill moved Saint Urban from Syracuse into the former Veritas space in May 2025. The Flatiron NoMad Partnership described Saint Urban as a French-inspired restaurant with a four-course prix fixe and a seven-course tasting menu. Hoodline noted that Saint Urban had closed before the new restaurant arrived.
Amphora is the third wine-led restaurant in the room, and the most cellar-focused so far. Eater NY put its collection at more than 2,500 labels, one of the largest wine cellars in the city. Executive chef Jack Logue previously worked at the Lambs Club and Betony, and wine director Chris Miller is also a Lambs Club alum. Miller's list focuses on Burgundy, Northern Rhône, Piedmont and Champagne, with producers including Domaine de la Romanée-Conti, Coche-Dury, Raveneau and Rousseau. The Flatiron NoMad Partnership's October roundup lists it as a recently opened neighbor, serving dinner Tuesday through Saturday.
Prices come from the restaurant's three- and four-course menu dated October 24:
| Format | Menu price | Amphora pairing | Reserve pairing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Three courses | $125 | $85 | $165 |
| Four courses | $155 | $125 | $215 |
A four-course dinner with the reserve pairing comes to $370 per person before tax and tip, so for most neighbors the table is an occasion. The cheaper way in is the bar. Time Out New York reported à la carte dining at a five-seat bar, along with a signature tasting menu with wine pairings. The restaurant's site lists bar small plates as their own format, next to the three-course, four-course and tasting menus. With only five seats, the bar is a better bet early in the week than on a Saturday.
The same pattern at a food-hall counter
The pattern holds at a much smaller scale on 14th Street. Kebabwala closed its stall at Time Out Market Union Square, at 124 East 14th Street, in September. On Monday, October 19, Lou Yau Kee debuted at the same food hall, at Irving Place. Eater NY described it as a popular stop for Singaporean comfort food, especially Hainan chicken rice. Eater wrote that the stall is "back" at the market, and that it joins the existing Lou Yau Kee location at Vanderbilt Market.
Lou Yau Kee came back without needing a new storefront, into a food hall the neighborhood already uses.
The one site still being built
The exception is 38 Gramercy Park, the one place in the neighborhood where something is going up from scratch. On October 12, Arlene Harrison of the Gramercy Park Block Association shared the developer's answers to neighbor complaints about late concrete pours and water leaking around a hydrant.
Here is what the developer said, as relayed by the block association:
- Concrete: The developer hopes to finish the bulk of its heavy concrete work toward the end of November, if conditions allow. The block association called that an estimate, not a confirmed completion date.
- Notice: Because pour timing depends on weather, inspections, site conditions and concrete availability, the developer is reluctant to circulate a schedule that may change. It says it will make an effort to give advance notice of especially disruptive work or extended hours when practical.
- Water: The site expects to switch to permanent water service in the coming weeks, after which the hydrant will no longer be its main water source. The developer says the sidewalk leak appears to originate in underground piping owned by the NYC Department of Environmental Protection and says it is still pressing DEP for repairs, but no repair date has been given.
The block association asks neighbors to keep reporting problems by email, with the location, date, time and photographs when helpful.
The seasonal tenant on 14th Street
One more familiar arrival is due on 14th Street this month. Urbanspace lists the Union Square Holiday Market for November 12 through December 24, 2026. NYC Tourism places it at University Place and East 14th Street. That's the far end of the same street where Lou Yau Kee just reopened, about a block and a half west of Time Out Market at Irving Place.
Back at 190 Third Avenue, a building that started as a German rathskeller has now added Triona's Vintage Sporting Club to its record. On Saturdays and Sundays, the bar opens at 11 a.m.
Fitting a new use into a landmarked room like Scheffel Hall is the kind of work Falchiere Group does on the renovation side of our practice. If you own a Gramercy property with history and want to know what it could become, schedule a consultation with our team.